It is altogether appropriate for the Witching Season that we turn some attention upon what perhaps was one of the finest horror/thriller pictures ever made: Roger Corman’s
The Masque Of The Red Death (1964).
Roger Corman has long been infamous as the great schlockmeister of Hollywood; a reputation earned from having cranked out numerous cheap B-grade films through the 1950s and later the 1970s to make a fast buck – which he most assuredly did succeed at doing. Not a single picture Corman ever made failed to show a profit, no matter how thin it might have turned out to be in the final accounting. After having compiled a canon of some of the hokiest B sci-fi/monster thrillers and hamfisted social “message” movies ever made, it was around 1960 that Corman suddenly launched off on making a string of remarkably well-crafted horror films based on the works of Edgar Allen Poe, scripted by talented genre writers such as Richard Matheson and Charles Beaumont. As with every Corman picture, these also were low-budget productions. Corman always knew how to squeeze a nickel, and he became quite adept at circumventing the limitations of budget by borrowing sets and costumes left over from other productions and squirreling away monies saved on each of his assigned production budgets by finishing each project ahead of time and then ploughing the leftover cash into the next film. He also got great performances out of his casts, headlined by the great Vincent Price, whose very presence and mellifluous elocution lent dignity to any film he appeared in. The first of these productions,
House Of Usher (1960), set the pattern for the series: Price leading a cast of mostly rookies and unknowns, always few in number, and turning upon costuming, acting, and a tight psychological story to create the horror absent of monsters or elaborate visual effects (though most of the films in the series would feature at least one “hallucinatory” scene rather effectively and cheaply done with some basic photographic artistry, scored with appropriately eerie music, of course), turning upon the evils human beings inflict upon one another rather than the terror of the supernatural. It proved a very effective formula. For 1963, Corman finally got around to making
The Masque Of The Red Death, which he had put off because he had felt that elements of it would have been too similar to Ingmar Bergman’s
The Seventh Seal (1957) and he wanted a few years to pass before attempting his project. The timing turned out to be just right, for the British government had recently enacted a policy of granting tax advantages and subsidies to movie producers who worked in England, using mostly English actors and production crews. There would also be castle sets that could be borrowed from English studios to give a far more lavish look to the finished film With a much reworked script from Charles Beaumont and R. Wright Campbell in hand, Price and lovely scream queen Hazel Court in tow, Corman readily accepted American International Pictures studio boss Samuel Z Arkoff's suggestion that they go to London to make the movie. The result was a picture which would end up becoming a classic of the genre beyond anyone’s expectations.
Of Roger Corman’s many movies,
The Masque Of The Red Death is unique for its depth. Having to craft an entire ninety minute photoplay around two Poe short stories, “The Masque Of The Red Death” and “Hop-Frog”, the resulting work spins out a story of human depravity and hope. On the night Prince Prospero (Price), a medieval Italian duke, stages his annual banquet for the nobles of the countryside and also, as per personal custom, invites the landed serfs of the nearby village of Catania to the banquet as well — ostensibly out of generosity but in all likelihood as entertainment for his wealthier guests — the villagers, far from expressing their usual servility or any hint of gratitude for their overlord’s apparent generosity, are rebellious thanks to a prophecy from a mysterious holy man (in actuality, Death, played by John Westbrook) on the hill that the people of Catania would soon be delivered from Prospero’s tyranny. When the old woman who brought the message of the prophecy screams out in agony, she is found to be a victim of the Red Death, a virulent plague which has periodically ravaged the countryside. Prospero orders his guards to take captive a local village girl, Francesca (Jane Asher), her father and fiancĂ©e (the latter two for his own amusement) and then to burn the village to the ground, regardless of the oncoming winter. Shutting himself and his guests within the walls of his castle in seeming safety from the plague without, and having become fascinated by Francesca, Prospero proceeds upon a project to seduce and corrupt the innocent girl into the worship of Satan. Subjecting her to continual displays of cruelty from his noble guests while alternatively assuming a protective, even paternal attitude toward the girl, Francesca is gradually stripped of her hope and dignity until she is brought very near the point of succumbing to Prospero when Death appears upon the night of the masque, and at the stroke of midnight brings down upon Prospero and his guests their grisly and well-deserved fate.

What makes
The Masque Of The Red Death unique in the horror genre is the degree to which the movie examines the nature of man. Prospero and his wife Juliana (Court) are Satanists, having adopted the worship of the Fallen Angel in hopes of achieving immortality through the Devil's favor. While outwardly confident and contemptuous, Prospero is a mortally frightened man who cannot accept the prospect of his own demise. He is willing to sacrifice everyone in his orbit, including his wife, to Satan in order to escape death. Juliana has deceived herself into believing that she can wed Satan and thus ascend higher in his favor than Prospero, but still seeks her husband's continuing grace by finally agreeing to undergo ceremonies she has held herself back from now that Francesca has entered into the scene.
“How truly realistic women are,” sneers Prospero.
“Finally you are ready to undergo the most terrible rites and incantations in order to secure your position here”. Juliana, despite her own veneer of outward superiority, fears being cast out of Prospero's home, as he is well aware of, and in the sort of world that was early 14th century Italy that meant impoverishment at best and death at worst. As for all of Prospero's friends, they constantly seek to curry his favor because he is the wealthiest and most powerful of their circle. To fall outside of Prospero's grace is to risk ruin and, in the case of Count Scarlatti (Paul Whitsun-Jones) who arrived late to the castle, death from the plague when Prospero refuses him admittance. Scarlatti finds himself unable to buy his way in even by the offer of his own wife to Prospero for his sexual amusement, and the Prince “spares” his friend by killing him with a crossbow bolt in the heart before tossing a dagger to Scarlatti's widow so that she can spare herself the Red Death as well. The other noble guests within are more than willing to degrade themselves as Prospero sees fit to stay under his protection and gain ever more wealth. On the night of the masque, Prospero showers them with gold and precious stones from the balcony over the main hall.
“Look at them. Look at them! Like starving men scrambling for a few crusts of bread. All rich beyond imagining and all greedy for more,” he says to Francesca with undisguised contempt. Then, there is Alfredo (Patrick Magee), presumably Prospero's closest friend, who enjoys cruelty and corruption for their own sakes and is an outright bully. He imagines himself Prospero's superior but is a bigger fool than he is capable of apprehending, and is quite heedless of the revenge being laid out for him by the dwarf dancer Hoptoad (Skip Martin), in payback for his assault of Esmeralda (Verina Greenlaw), Hoptoad's wife, earlier in the evening. He has no clue of how he is being led to his own death by the cunning dwarf, who successfully plays on Alfredo's overweening vanity as part of a plan to engineer escape for himself and Esmeralda from the castle. Alfredo's ultimate fate is indeed a very gruesome one.


Against all this, Francesca and her fiancee Gino (David Weston) have only love. But that is what undergirds their own religious faith and gives them strength. It is Francesca's faith that most intrigues Prospero and even, despite himself, attracts him on a deeper level than he is willing to admit. At one point, Prospero wonders if Francesca is willing to risk everything for the sake of love, and later when she offers herself to Prospero's mercy in order to spare Gino from being cast out of the castle, he confesses that she almost makes him doubt his own convictions. Likewise, with the strength of love within him, Gino is able to find new courage – with only a little prompting from Death – to try to turn the surviving villagers away from degrading themselves before Prospero to buy their own survival and then to go back to the castle to try to rescue Francesca. Even when she is beginning to crack under the relentless psychological pressure put upon her, Francesca still manages to avoid completely tumbling into Prospero's grasp by the time Death makes his appearance at the masque because love has not been extinguished in her even if she has lost hope. There is indeed one brief moment when she gives the mad prince a tender kiss when she is sent off to the battlements of the castle, knowing also that she will not see him again.

Prospero combines the qualities of psychologist, torturer, and father-confessor, and wields all of them as both weapons and surgical instruments to “instruct” people. His grandfather was an inquisitor for the church who tortured over three hundred people to “save their souls”, which he relates to Francesca. He casually speaks to her of how he locked a friend of his in a yellow room in the castle for three years, after which the man could never again look upon the sun or a flower, as a demonstration of how easily a man's mind can be twisted. Later, he tells her of how a falcon is trained as a hunting bird by temporarily sewing the eyes shut and forcing it to endure the whims of the trainer “until her will is submerged and she learns to serve”. Prospero was also adept at twisting virtues to justify his cruelties and to outwit Francesca, who had no learning and could not rebut his logic. He uses this to justify putting Gino and Ludovico (Nigel Green) to a death challenge as punishment for their sin of killing three of his guards, and later in a warped argument that by slaughtering the last survivors of Catania he was actually showing them mercy by sparing them the agonies of the Red Death.
In any viewing of the movie, it is evident that Prospero is subjecting the girl to a classic brainwashing procedure. Cut off from her family and home, thrust into unfamiliar surroundings, Francesca is bombarded both by the wanton displays of debaunchery from the people in the castle and by Prospero's dogma, both of which steadily break down her sense of reality. Acting as protector and instructor, he simultaneously presents himself to Francesca as her only source of safety and knowledge, and she has little means to resist the continuing instruction in his worldview:
“Somewhere in the human mind, my dear Francesca, lies the key to our existence. My ancestors tried to find it, and to open the door that separates us from our Creator.”
“But you need no doors to find God! If you believe—”
“Believe? If you believe, you are gullible. Can you look about this world and believe in the goodness of a god who rules it? Famine, Pestilence, War, Disease and Death! They rule this world.”
“There is also life and love and hope!”
“Very little hope, I assure you. No. If a god of love ever did exist, he is long since dead. Someone, some... thing, rules in his place.”
She is stripped of all the outward symbols of her former life, such as her crucifix and her own clothing, and is forced by circumstance to depend upon Prospero. The shocks to her sensibilities delivered by everything she witnesses in the castle, the murder of her own father before her eyes, the casting-out of her lover into the plague-ravaged wasteland beyond the castle walls, and the death of Juliana who attempted to help her and her men escape the castle (to further secure her own place rather than any genuine concern for their safety, of course), completes her isolation from the reality she had known before her captivity, while each hope is crushed one by one. By the time Alfredo is burned to death wearing an ape costume at the masque, after being rendered helpless by Hoptoad, she is desolate within and losing the last of her ability to resist Prospero.
“My life is done. What's left I give to you tonight,” she says dully. Were it not for Death's timely intervention, she certainly would have been lost forever into Prospero's madness.
As with the entity played by Bengt Ekrot in
The Seventh Seal, Death here is similarly a sympathetic and to a limited extent even a helpful being who is merely performing a necessary task in the world. He takes only those whose time is up, but points Gino in the right way; hearing his confession of his own fears and inadequacies and helping the young man to again find his courage at the very moment he needs it to rescue his beloved. He prevents Gino from simply charging down from the battlements where he would have been cut down by the guards. He sends Francesca to safety before bringing down upon Prospero his own demise. After the end, Death is seen happily playing a Tarocci game with a child who was one of only six in the village to survive both the plague and Prospero's depredations.
Death is also a judge, pronouncing sentence upon Prospero while forcing him to at last confront his own folly though it is far too late for him to profit from the lesson. At first taking him to be an emissary from Satan, Prospero gleefully recounts how he alone had the right faith when others doubted, building a temple to the Devil, corrupting all his friends into his cult, promising them safety from the plague and setting them up to fall victim to it – which has just occurred when Death infects the assembled throng and sets them into a
danse macabre. “You presumed too much,” Death remarks, to which a still unknowing Prospero concedes while adding that
“It is a fine jest, one that would amuse Satan.” “Would it?” replies Death rhetorically. It is after Prospero makes his “generous” request to spare Francesca and her subsequent departure from the masque when Death brings reality crashing down down upon the prince:
“Thank you, Excellency. For the girl.”
“Why do you call me Excellency? I have no title.”
“Well, I thought as the emissary of Satan—”
“He is not my master. Death has no master.”
“But Satan rules the universe. I made a pact with him.”
“He does not rule alone, and your pact with him will not save you.”
“There is no other god! Satan killed him!”
“Each man creates his own god for himself. His own heaven, his own hell.”
And when Prospero demands to see the face of the figure he's talking to and pulls off the mask to see his own blood-coated face staring back at him:
“Your hell, Prospero. And the moment of your death.”
Only at that moment does Prospero at last confront reality and he still attempts to flee from it, as he has been doing his entire life. Desperately clawing his way through the throng of infected revelers all falling upon him, Prospero reaches the Black Chapel as his last sanctuary, only to find Death already waiting for him there. Unable to unlock the door, the prince cowers from the oncoming spectre.
“Why should you be afraid to die?” Death says to Prospero,
“Your soul has been dead for a long time.”
Though both
The Seventh Seal and
The Masque Of The Red Death shared certain thematic similarities, they differed in one critical aspect: where the existential terror confronting Antonius Block was his uncertainty that God and an afterlife actually existed, Prospero's was the certain dread of his own oblivion spurring his effort to run away from it. Block wanted answers, Prospero sought escape. In the course of this flight, Prospero destroyed his own soul in the service of a folly and sacrificed hundreds of lives to it. His was an empty existence spent in the pursuit of power, wealth, and immortality. He corrupted others and destroyed himself long before his own final demise, and his end was one of stark terror. Prospero truly did create his own hell.
In many ways,
The Masque Of The Red Death is far more a philosophical rather than a horror movie. Its themes touch upon some of the deepest questions confronting and confounding human understanding. Greed, cruelty, depravity, the amoral decadence of the ruling class, and self-deception are laid bare for examination, as are love, mercy, generosity. The true source of horror lies in human evil rather than from any supernatural agency, and the one supernatural element of the movie, the figure of Death himself, takes on an allegorical aspect not unlike his depiction in Catholic morality-plays of the medieval era. The psychology of power is exposed for what it is: the ultimately doomed attempt to control everything like a team of trained horses. While the opposite lesson is that the only true source of human strength is love. A most unexpected message from a horror film, to be certain.